The Sisters of Straygarden Place

Starred review from July 27, 2020
Since their parents vanished seven years ago, leaving them a list of rules (“Do not leave the house. Do not go into the grass. Wait for us. Sleep darkly”), the Ballastian sisters—10-year-old Pavonine, 12-year-old Mayhap, and 14-year-old Winnow—have lived alone at Straygarden Place, a semi-sentient house that fulfills their every need. Unable to sleep without the droomhunds, which settle into their minds at night, the sisters await their parents’ return. When Winnow ventures into the forbidding silver grass outside—which perpetually whispers to the girls and tries to creep inside—and comes down with an uncanny affliction, Mayhap delves into Straygarden’s secrets to find a cure. Instead, she discovers a strange girl who claims to be the source of the house’s magic, as well as the shocking reason behind her parents’ disappearance. Chewins (The Turnaway Girls) weaves a vivid, otherworldly tale of family and secrets, with a gothic setting that serves as a character in its own right. Through themes of identity, forgiveness, and longing, Mayhap’s unpredictable quest becomes intensely personal, especially as the sisters reinvent their familial relationship. Ages 10–14. Agent: Patricia Nelson, Marsal Lyon Literary.

August 1, 2020

Gr 4-6-Mayhap Ballastian and her sisters Winnow and Pavonine have been trapped in Straygarden Place since their parents disappeared several years earlier. Luckily, the house takes care of everything the sisters need, providing meals on demand and droomhunds to darken their sleep and keep them company. It isn't safe to go outside the tall magical grasses surrounding the house-but one terrible day, Winnow goes wandering in the grasses anyway. From that point forward, everything that the sisters knew to be true starts to unravel as Mayhap must save her family and herself. Along the way, she meets the Mysteriessa of Straygarden Place, who claims to use magic to take care of the house and the Ballastians...but can she be trusted? The magic of Straygarden Place is dreamy and imbued with dread, providing a strong setting for Mayhap's trials. Though at times the surreality of the world makes it hard to follow, the plot and characters are engaging enough to make up for it. VERDICT A strong opening and consistent sense of urgency makes this an ideal choice for reluctant readers interested in slightly spooky fantasy. Give to fans of Neil Gaiman's Coraline, Kenneth Oppel's The Nest, or The House in Poplar Wood by K.E. Ormsbee.-Kelsey Socha, Springfield City Lib., MA

Copyright 2020 School Library Journal, LLC Used with permission.

July 1, 2020
Mayhap Ballastian and her sisters have lived locked inside Straygarden Place for years, ever since their parents left them. Staying inside keeps them safe from the rapacious silver grass that surrounds the house, and in any case, the house itself looks after them -- feeds and clothes them, supplies them with books and information. But when eldest sister Winnow ventures out and returns wounded by the grass, Mayhap sets out to find how to cure her. Instead, she finds the house's secret inhabitant, the Mysteriessa, whose identity and purpose threaten Mayhap's very being. Chewins's story revolves around guilt and belonging, with a rather cumbersome plot maneuvering readers toward a scene of restoration and acceptance -- and a surprising twist ending. But Straygarden Place is pure confection and provides the sparkle to the imagining, with its fancy furniture, food, and clothing; transporting carpets; and self-tucking coverlets. There's confection, too, in Chewins's abundant similes: a door as "black and shiny as Italian vinegar"; roots "as white as marzipan"; bones that felt "as brittle as burned sugar."

(Copyright 2020 by The Horn Book, Incorporated, Boston. All rights reserved.)

November 1, 2020
Mayhap Ballastian and her sisters have lived locked inside Straygarden Place for years, ever since their parents left them. Staying inside keeps them safe from the rapacious silver grass that surrounds the house, and in any case, the house itself looks after them -- feeds and clothes them, supplies them with books and information. But when eldest sister Winnow ventures out and returns wounded by the grass, Mayhap sets out to find how to cure her. Instead, she finds the house's secret inhabitant, the Mysteriessa, whose identity and purpose threaten Mayhap's very being. Chewins's story revolves around guilt and belonging, with a rather cumbersome plot maneuvering readers toward a scene of restoration and acceptance -- and a surprising twist ending. But Straygarden Place is pure confection and provides the sparkle to the imagining, with its fancy furniture, food, and clothing; transporting carpets; and self-tucking coverlets. There's confection, too, in Chewins's abundant similes: a door as "black and shiny as Italian vinegar"; roots "as white as marzipan"; bones that felt "as brittle as burned sugar." Deirdre F. Baker

(Copyright 2020 by The Horn Book, Incorporated, Boston. All rights reserved.)

Starred review from June 1, 2020
In an enchanted house, three sisters face confusing dangers. Years ago, Mamma and Pappa silently walked out of the large, formal, and daunting Straygarden Place, leaving their daughters a cryptic note: "Do not leave the house. / Do not go into the grass. / Wait for us. / Sleep darkly." The silver grass outside looms taller than the house itself; always aggressive, it plugs the keyholes, blocks the windows, shakes the walls, and hisses words. It tries to get in. One day, eldest sister Winnow goes outdoors--and when she returns, nothing is the same. The house still nurturingly feeds and clothes the girls using magic, but Winnow sickens and begins to turn silver. Unable to talk, Winnow rages incoherently at middle sister and third-person protagonist Mayhap. The relationships among Mayhap, Winnow, and youngest sister Pavonine tip sideways with anger, bafflement, and terror. Even each girl's personally bonded droomhund--a small black dog who squeezes physically into its girl's brain when she needs darkness for sleeping--can't provide comfort, and Winnow's droomhund is impossibly missing. Why does the aroma of coffee make Mayhap feel like she's smothering? Who's the sudden fourth girl in the house, and what has she woven out of "dirt and bats' lungs...the darkness of the sky and the silk of the moon...[and]...coffee"? Chewins' prose is exquisite, her eerie concepts heart-wrenching. All characters are white. Superb, spooky, and unforgettable. (Fantasy/horror. 10-14)

COPYRIGHT(2020) Kirkus Reviews, ALL RIGHTS RESERVED.