November 9, 2009
Harris, a reporter for National Journal
, details the rise of a “band of mavericks” in national security and intelligence organizations that has erected “an American surveillance state.” In this timely and admirably balanced account, Harris focuses on the role of a handful of key figures, including Reagan-era National Security Adviser John Poindexter, as they campaigned for information technology to identify terrorists. The controversial Poindexter started the campaign after the 1983 bombing of Marine barracks in Lebanon; the mission was imbued with greater urgency after September 11; with the support of the Bush administration, the National Security Agency (NSA) acquired a research project that Poindexter had developed called Total Information Awareness that uses advanced data-mining techniques to collect mountains of data—and has trapped countless innocent citizens in the NSA’s “electronic nets.” After the NSA’s warrantless surveillance was exposed in 2005, Congress passed largely cosmetic reforms that left the surveillance state intact. Harris carefully examines how the nexus between terrorism and technology has complicated the age-old “conflict between security and liberty” and calls for a national debate on the issue. This informative and dramatic narrative is an excellent place to start.
December 1, 2009
National Journal Intelligence and Homeland Security correspondent Harris investigates how the American government has acquired unprecedented surveillance power.
When the details of the Total Information Awareness system that John Poindexter was building for the Pentagon became public in 2002, civil-liberties advocates indignantly objected to what they saw as a vast, creepy surveillance program that spied on Americans, notwithstanding any protection it provided against terrorist attack. The fallout forced Poindexter to leave government for the second time—the first followed his involvement in the Iran Contra Scandal—but his dream of an electronic surveillance system that could detect security threats, digest information and convert it into a useful picture to preempt terrorism survived, albeit without the attendant privacy protections Poindexter had envisioned. Those safeguards were rejected ultimately as too costly and technologically demanding by the"watchers" who inherited the program and later enshrined many of its practices in law. Their names and deeds loom large in Harris's story about the emergence of the surveillance state, but the author rightly centers on Poindexter, whose high-level, hands-on experience with terrorism dates back to the'80s attack on the Beirut Marine barracks and the Achille Lauro hijacking. Despite his past, the government desperately needed his expertise in the wake of 9/11. Whether discussing the relationships among various intelligence agencies, the political component of any strategy, the trade-offs between security and privacy, or recounting the riveting story of the Army's aborted Able Danger program, Harris displays an exquisite understanding of the intricacies of his topic and a remarkable sensitivity to the genuine concerns of the watchers and their critics. Although he's skeptical about whether pattern analysis of data really catches terrorists, the author acknowledges the new administration's disinclination to dismantle what's been assembled and their fear of the endless recriminations that would follow another attack on the order of 9/11.
A sharply written, wise analysis of the complex mashup of electronic sleuthing, law, policy and culture.
(COPYRIGHT (2009) KIRKUS REVIEWS/NIELSEN BUSINESS MEDIA, INC. ALL RIGHTS RESERVED.)
February 12, 2010
Focusing on the last 30 years, Harris (staff correspondent, National Journal) shows how Admiral John Poindexter, formerly President Reagan's national security adviser, was hired by the Bush administration after 9/11 to devise the Total Information Awareness program. Harris documents how its equipment and people remain the foundation of current U.S. counterterrorism efforts, but data overload and interagency communication gaps still prevent all valuable information from being analyzed or acted on, while innumerable people are tracked electronically. Harris shows how covert programs have been instituted by the government to bypass legal restrictions. He makes use of his own interviews with government employees and corporate officials and knows how to include drama to spice up his tales of political maneuvering and paper shuffling. Ultimately, the question remains unanswered: What is the proper and effective means of providing national security in a nation such as ours? Verdict Readers of current events who follow this topic, will want to read this alongside Mark Andrejevic's iSpy. They'll appreciate Harris's accessible writing and his dramatic scenes, somewhat reminiscent of Bob Woodward's work. Students will appreciate the endnotes, although there is no bibliography. (Index not seen.)-Daniel K. Blewett, Coll. of DuPage Lib., Glen Ellyn, IL
Copyright 2010 Library Journal, LLC Used with permission.
August 1, 2015
Explores the history of attacks against U.S. interests; terrorism and the American response to it; and the debate between freedom and security in the networked era, as well as the lack of provable results from the increase of dragnet web traffic tracking. (LJ 2/15/10)
Copyright 2015 Library Journal, LLC Used with permission.